On Voice by Annmarie Miles
I heard my husband speaking on the phone the other day and
he used a phrase that was not his. It was something only an Irish person would
say. It’s not surprising really after 19 years of marriage, some of my brogue
was bound to rub off. But it got me thinking again about ‘voice.’ I felt
in that moment, he was using mine.
This is me a few years ago. No idea what I was saying, but I was talking about writing Photo credit: Denise Kennedy |
I love spending time on voice and dialogue in my
fiction. My first novel will be published soon, so rather than having to
capture my characters voices in the smaller word count of short stories, I’ve
been able to allow them to express themselves, and reveal themselves in
their speech. One of my bugbears is speech tags and I’m always wrestling
with getting the right amount in. As I mentioned, I love dialogue, and I want
readers to know who is speaking, by the voice, rather than reams of he said/she
said. I only use the alternative tags, such as; he shouted, she murmured,
he whispered etc if necessary. I don’t use them if all I’m doing is disguising
overkill in the he said/she said department. It’s a hard balance to strike
and as we enter the final proofing stage of my first long piece of fiction, I
hope I’ve managed it.
At writing group last week, one of our members mentioned she has a character who won’t come to heel. My friend has plans for the
character but every time she sits down to write, the character insists on going
another way. Every one of us around the table nodded in agreement. I'm sure other writers
reading this will understand. We went on
to talk about some of our characters as if they were disobedient children.
I wonder if there is a naughty step for characters.
I wonder if there is a naughty step for characters.
As frustrating as it can be, I do love when it happens. For
me, it means I’ve given my character their voice and I must let them be true to
it. I might love a sentence or a scene, but if it’s not sitting right with me,
it’s often because my character would not respond in that way, and I must
rewrite.
As well as reading the Psalms devotionally, I sometimes read
them from the point of view of David as a writer. He doesn't only speak from his own point of view. He quotes enemies, those with seeking, searching hearts, and God himself.
Sometimes I feel as if he's quoting me. Of course, it’s really the other way around,
but I wonder if God has given us the ability to hear our own voices, written by
David. The Psalmist cries out to God in anguish, fear, uncertainty, joy,
determination, worship, praise… and every so often I think, that’s what I’d
say. That’s my voice. It can feel as authentic as if I'd written it myself. The sign of a great Writer :)
Annmarie Miles is from Dublin, Ireland.
She lives with her husband Richard who is a pastor in the Eastern Valley of Gwent, in South Wales. She writes short stories, magazine articles, devotional pieces for Christian radio, and blogs about her faith at www.auntyamo.com Her first collection of short stories published in 2013, is called 'The Long & The Short of it'. Her second collection, 'A Sense of the Sea and other stories,' was published in 2018. She is currently editing a non-fiction book about being an overweight Christian called, 'Have mercy on me O Lord, a slimmer.'
She lives with her husband Richard who is a pastor in the Eastern Valley of Gwent, in South Wales. She writes short stories, magazine articles, devotional pieces for Christian radio, and blogs about her faith at www.auntyamo.com Her first collection of short stories published in 2013, is called 'The Long & The Short of it'. Her second collection, 'A Sense of the Sea and other stories,' was published in 2018. She is currently editing a non-fiction book about being an overweight Christian called, 'Have mercy on me O Lord, a slimmer.'
I love this. I have just written something myself about characters who refuse to do what they want us to. Glad to hear that others struggle with this too.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant, Annmarie. I love it when my character just takes over - mind you I do find myself deleting lots of their dialogue! Happy writing and hope it all goes well with your first published novel.
ReplyDeleteI do like the idea of naughty steps for characters. Or maybe they should get 'time out' or 100 lines if they don't cooperate. Hey, tell us a bit about your forthcoming novel in your bio at the end? I'd like to hear more.
ReplyDeleteI really like the way you speak of us hearing our voices in the Psalms. Truly a sign of a great writer. Loved this!
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting what you said about speech tags, I've never heard that expression before. I think the 'he said/she said' debate could go on for a long time, especially as after reading a thread on twitter about what should we write instead, I read a page from a Stephen King novel where he used 'said' with no problem at all. It's a sign of needing to get more writing done that I haven't experienced my characters misbehaving. Lots to think about, thank you!
ReplyDeleteYou're so right, Annmarie, about the Psalms how they speak in our own voice. For me, other parts of the Bible resonate in the same way - often just a phrase or a sentence.
ReplyDeleteI think we also have to give credit there to the translators of the Bible as well as the original authors. I'm currently reading The Message version, which is bringing so much freshness and new understanding. The Americanisms grate a little - back to your point about not being our voice - but otherwise the modern idiom makes me feel at home.
I can think of a couple of poetry books I have that are English translations of the original Italian and Welsh, one of which (in my opinion) works better than the other. Translation is so difficult and I think we should give more frequent credit to those whose writing includes this skill.