Why Was Jesus Celibate? by Bobbie Ann Cole
Last week, my lovely, free Yeshua Group Online discussed the conundrum that Jesus was both celibate and a Jew. The things is that Jews are not supposed to be celibate. No, Jews marry. “The deliberate renunciation of marriage is all but completely alien to Judaism.” says the Jewish Virtual Library.
A SECOND WIFE IN WAITING
This is so important that, in second temple times, when Jesus walked on earth,
the Chief Priest could only enter the Holy of Holies on Yom Kippur to
atone for his people if he was a married man. Since polygamy among
priests was not acceptable then, they would line up
a reserve wife, just in case something terrible should happen to the first one
at the last minute. In so, the second woman could step in to take her
place.
Chabad Jews declare: “The first mitzvah (a good deed commanded by God) in the Torah is to “be fruitful and multiply." As the verse in Genesis states: "And G‑d said to them, 'Be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth.'" (Gen. 1:28) This is considered a "great mitzvah" and in some cases even, "overrides certain other laws.”
The Shulhan Aruch,
a table of the rules Jews should live by, states: "Every man is obliged to
marry in order to fulfill the duty of procreation, and whoever is not engaged
in propagating the race is as if he shed blood, diminishing the Divine image
and causing His Presence to depart from Israel" ( Shulḥan Arukh:
EH 1:1).
Strong language. They sound like they really mean it!
JESUS AND PAUL - THE
JEWISH EXCEPTIONS?
And yet, curiously, it
would seem, we find Jesus and Paul advocating celibacy. Jesus says: “There are
those who choose to live like eunuchs for the sake of the kingdom of heaven. The
one who can accept this should accept it,” (Matthew 19:12).
While, discouraging
divorce, Paul states: “I wish that all of you were as I am,” and, “It is good
to stay unmarried, as I do.” (1 Cor 7:7, 8).
Were they the only Jews
on the planet in favour of celibacy?
ESSENES
Some evidence exists that
the Essenes were a celibate sect at the time of Jesus, implying Jesus and Paul were not alone.
There has been some speculation that Jesus was an Essene, but there is no evidence to point to that.
However, since there are women’s graves among those of the Essenes at Qumran and some Essene writings among the Dead Sea Scrolls contain marriage stipulations for their members, it is clear that not all Essenes were celibate.
It is now thought that
some Essenes may have lived celibately for a season only, keeping
themselves pure and holy, (ritually clean) while they gave themselves over to
writing for God.
Jewish Law says that
bodily emissions, such as semen or menstrual blood, render a person unclean.
To this day, Orthodox Jewish men will never shake a woman’s hand because she
could be menstruating and shaking her hand could render them unclean.
Essenes who were engaged in holy writing were therefore perforce only men, because women’s menstrual cycle could render them unclean.
These
male scribes remained ritually clean and therefore fit to write holy words by avoiding sexual relations
with women. They were thus celibate during their writing stint,
but returned to normal life at home afterwards,
We never read in the Bible of Jesus being rendered unclean, despite his touching dead bodies, lepers and even a woman with a long-term discharge of blood, all of whom in theory would have this effect on him.
In fact, it was the reverse that applied: Jesus’ purity rendered the unclean clean.
Despite his unassailable, perpetual purity, he remained a lifelong celibate who rejoiced in and advocated singleness. Why so?
THE BRIDEGROOM
Our online group discussed how Jesus actually did ‘marry’. He first demonstrated his role as bridegroom at a wedding in Cana, where he changed water to wine.
His miracle draws our
attention to his identity as bridegroom, since the bridegroom was
responsible for providing the wine at 1st century Jewish weddings. (The
steward naturally assumed that the groom had supplied the fine wine at this wedding and complimented him, (John 2:9-10))
There were six jars of
water that Jesus transformed into wine, this number being the days of the creation,
after which sin entered the world through the first man, Adam. Purification
from sin 'entered the world, (the public arena), at this second creation through the wine that stood
for Jesus’ purifying blood: he was 'the lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world.'
MARY THE FIRST
DISCIPLE
The Bridegroom married
us, his followers, starting, in a mystical way, with his mother Mary, whom he addressed
at Cana as ‘Woman’, demonstrating thus that she stood for all women.
Henceforth, all Jesus’ followers would be his ‘mother’, ‘sister’ or ‘brother’— his family, cleaving to him as a wife does to her husband, and becoming one flesh. His addressing Mary as ‘woman’ again on the cross, reminds us of her as the first bride that she has held since Cana. Her role is that of every believer: to tend his sheep and feed his lambs. As a bride she is a disciple, (Acts 1:14).
No doubt, Mary was present at Pentecost, when the disciples were equipped for their mission through the
Holy Spirit, descending on them as tongues of flame. This took place on the Jewish
festival of Shavuot, the self same day when Jews remember Moses, descending the mountain wielding
God’s Law on heavy tablets of stone.
We, his church, are both
Jesus’ bride and his children, the living proof that he was obedient to the
command to be fruitful and multiply, in a way that no one else ever has done or could
do.
With thanks to all who contributed
their ideas at this meeting of my Yeshua Group Online.
I look forward to reading your views in the comments below.
Bobbie Ann Cole is a Christian writer, speaker and writing teacher.
Through the Book Compass Course Bobbie will personally help you to fully prepare you to write the book God has put on your heart..
A done for you version of this course for the overwhelmed, the bewildered and the busy is the Book Compass Kickstart Course, where she interviews you and provides your book plan for you.
Ask her about bespoke coaching options here. https://www.bobbieanncole.co.uk/contact/.
A no-strings half hour Zoom call is always available, to help you with any book writing problem.
It is always fascinating to read the background to the Bible stories in your blogposts, Bobbie.
ReplyDeleteI am glad you find them interesting, Sue. This one is my best so far, I'm feeling, because I brought the dilemma to my group, not really knowing the solution and came away feeling I had learned a lot, and the others, too.
DeleteThis really piqued my interest. I also read from somewhere that because Lord Jesus remained celibate, catholic priests don't marry. Since He is the example for mankind and His words are to be adhered to, He seems to purport by the statement you made above that marriage is a choice for those who wish to for the kingdom's sake. So this is why he stayed celibate. I think this is in keeping with the fact that God gives man a choice in everything! It was Lord Jesus's choice to stay celibate. Thanks Bobbie for your very interesting post. Blessings.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteI'm glad you found this interesting, Sophia. Our debate at my Yeshua Group Online involved Catholics and ardent Protestants - some views diverged but everything was said with enormous grace and we reached a great consensus
DeleteYes, Catholic priests are celibate. Marriage is the alternative to celibacy in Catholic teaching - so there is a choice, your calling as a Christian is "a or b" . Ordinary non-ordained people are to marry and participate in being fruitful and multiplying. (Of course in today's world, things have changed for many reasons, and a command to be fruitful has always been more dangerous and more burdensome for a woman than for a man, but that's something we could discuss for ever!)
ReplyDeleteThe enlightenment brought by my Yeshua Group Online that Yeshua was fruitful and multiplied through his bride was profound.
DeleteI was fascinated to read this post. Jesus's celibacy has teased and challenged many over the centuries. No wonder the conspiracy theorists love the idea he married Mary Magdalene and fathered children whose descendents live today! It is a powerful idea that captures the imagination yet it's also a dangerous idea, given human nature. The subjugation of women by men over the course of human history, to me, is explained by the fact of childbirth and its perils. That fact may be related to Jesus's celibacy on several levels.
ReplyDeleteInteresting perspective, Sheila - remembering God said he would 'multiply your pregnancies' to Eve. My own theory is that hunter/gatherer peoples were far more egalitarian. It was when we put down roots and built cities that power was deemed to be in the hands of men because of women's childbearing - always holding a child or one for a friend.
DeleteThis does not seem to me to be directly connected with Jesus' celibacy. How are you seeing that? Please explain.
Really interesting post, Bobbie. I think if Jesus or Paul had been married this would have distracted them from their intense ministry and therefore was the right thing for them. It doesn't mean that celibacy should be forced on priests e.g. as in the Catholic church, which can lead to sin. I think it is a state that God calls one to for a reason.
ReplyDeleteThanks for this comment, Sheila. Totally agree - in my presentation to the Yeshua Group Online I had a slide illustrating Corrie Ten Boom's witness to choosing celibacy.
Delete