Who Said Rejections Are Bad?
Making mistakes is a good thing, that is how we learn. This is what I’m constantly reminding my year 5 children. It worries me that today’s children believe failure is the ultimate disaster. One boy in my class (let’s call him Albert) received back his maths test. He had one question wrong and realised his mistake immediately. The conversation went something like this.
Albert: “Oh no, I got question 2b wrong. I’m so stupid. I read it wrong. I can’t believe it!”
Me: “That’s all right, Albert. You can see what you did, you won’t do that again. Making mistakes is how we learn.”
Albert: (silent tears trickling down his face) “But I would have got them all right. I would have got twenty out of twenty.”
Me: “But, look, you’ve done really well. Only one mistake.”
Albert: (tears are freely running down his face though he’s desperately trying not to cry). “But, I’m so stupid. It’s a silly mistake. I should have got it right.”
Me: "Seriously, Albert. Making mistakes is a good thing. Goodness, if you got everything right all of the time, I’d be out of a job! The most successful people in life made lots of mistakes before they became successful!"
Albert: (trying to joke through his tears but unsuccessful) "Ha Ha, you’re trying to tell me that mistakes are good, that's just ridiculous!"
Me: "Not ridiculous, Albert, in fact, I believe mistakes are so important that I’m going to give you a merit for it.
Albert: (incredulous) "You mean I will get merit every time I make a mistake? That’s just stupid!"
Me: "Actually, Albert, I’m giving you this merit because I want you to know that mistakes are not all bad as long as you learn from them. Have you learned from this one?"
Albert: "Yes."
Me: "I’m actually really proud of how you’re handling this, Albert. You definitely deserve this merit."
This is a true story – it actually happened on Thursday and it got me thinking about my blog post. How many of us don’t take a chance with our writing because we’re afraid we might fail? How many of us delay sending our work to a publisher because we think it might not be good enough? How many of us don’t send our work to large publishers because we’re afraid we’ll just get another rejection?
Who said rejections are bad? Aren’t they evidence that we’re courageous? We’re brave enough to make ourselves vulnerable? Perhaps instead of lamenting the rejections, we should celebrate! We should dust off our pride and start again!
So, I’ll start the ball rolling: please celebrate my rejections with me! I’ve had at least nine (and I’m still counting!) and I’m not giving up!
Who’s next?
Brilliant!! I loved the conversation with your pupil and what a valuable lesson to learn. Thank you Nikki
ReplyDeleteMy pleasure. X
DeleteI don't know why I've come up as anonymous! It's me!
DeleteHey! Hi you! Xxx
DeleteAw ... Albert is an example to us all!
ReplyDeleteIndeed. X
DeleteVery lovely post! So full of encouragement and advice. Yes we are courageous and and if we fall, we will rise again . Thanks for the hope. Thanks for Albert! Blessings.
ReplyDeleteLoved your reply to Albert ‘I’d be out of a job!’ Apart from submitting pieces for comment or rejection I tutor Chemistry students - always telling them it’s your mistakes that tell me more than your correct answers! But as a writer the boot is on the other foot…and I’m learning to learn from my mistakes and setbacks! Your post hit the target - thank you.
ReplyDeleteLove this. Wish I'd had a teacher like you!
ReplyDeleteI've just started an MA in Creative Writing and much of the course is critiquing each other's work. I'm finding it a positive experience because readers notice things I don't. So it gives me concrete things I can work on to improve, instead of just vague hope that I will.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant! I hope you learn lots (including by making lots of mistakes!)
DeletePerhaps I should after all go back and finish my creative writing degree.
DeleteThere is so much I enjoyed in reading this - wonderful.
ReplyDeleteThank you!
DeleteFab post! I say exactly the same to my Y6 children. And you're so right. Sending off our work, and being a writer at all actually is incredibly courageous. We should celebrate this.
ReplyDeleteLove the conversation with 'Albert' and hope he takes that lesson with him through life - otherwise he might be stymied by being a perfectionist which is a major enemy of every artist and writer. Julia Cameron in 'The Artist's Way' is very good about encouraging us to get the work out there, being ready to face criticism, but moving on if we meet rejection. Surely far healthier than hiding the manuscript away in a bottom drawer or the vault of our PC/laptop! There's always that possibility that someone somewhere will say 'Yes'...
ReplyDeleteThis is beautiful, thank you so sharing this!
ReplyDeleteWhat a wonderful post, and Eva and I loved your response to Albert. I took a risk by sending some of my work for an opportunity with a production company. I'll find out by end of October if I've been successful
ReplyDelete