#BathshebaToo
Imagine having one single uncomfortable story associated with your name. We still do this today; I have heard far more about Hermoso being kissed than her football success. What will her legacy be?
And the wife of Uriah? She slept with King David. That's her story. Everything went wrong after that in David's family life. You don't see many Bathshebas on the Sunday School register.
But this is not her whole story or identity. It's not even a fair snapshot. Who really was she? Does the biblical text give us any more clues? If you're interested, the references are at the end of the post. But let's try and get into Bathsheba's head a little by thinking about her circumstances.
She is a married woman who apparently does not yet have children - so perhaps still in the early months. Her husband is sold out in his work as a warrior for Israel, despite his non-Israelite heritage. He is away fighting for God.
Bathsheba is fairly young, but still old enough to run many aspects of home life, rising early to grind flour, to cook, to wash, to tend animals, to trade and probably even to brew beer. There are other people's children to help raise and many meals which take hours to prepare. It's likely she lives in a house with an open area in the centre, around which rooms on the ground floor house supplies and animals. Rooms upstairs will be added for sleeping quarters as the family grows.
I imagine that it is possible to see into the open area from a high vantage. Bathsheba, tired from work and the sticky heat, wants to freshen up. She collects water and washes herself. From the roof of the palace, a man notices her.
Here opinion divides. I see Bathsheba as a victim; David has spent his life watching and planning. Others have labelled her an opportunist, keen and willing to seduce the king. Either way, this was never going to play out well.
A knock on the door. A hasty march through the smelly streets. An audience with the king. In private. Does he offer her choice food and wine? Does he groom her? Is it rape? Would it have made any difference if it had been consensual in the world she lives in? Afterwards, confused and frightened, she returns to her home; a place which belongs not to her, but to a man. Just like she does. As she always will.
Daughter.
Wife.
Mistress.
Mother.
Perhaps she takes herself into the darkest room and closes the door and weeps into her clothes. Is this how the king treats people? There is no one to tell.
And as the days pass the moon completes a cycle but Bathsheba doesn't. This indiscretion cannot be kept secret.
Look through the story in 2 Samuel 11 and you'll see the word 'sent' appear many times. David sends people and messages over and over. It puts him in a position of power and authority. In two places however, he does not do the sending, and the word is so frequent that it is certainly a literary choice.
In verse 5 Bathsheba sends David a simple, frightening message: I am pregnant. The one thing she sends is the one thing David cannot control. This undermines his power and in his confusion David digs a deeper hole. He sends for Bathsheba's husband, tries to send him to his wife, tries to hide or 'unsend' his error.
Bathsheba would have no reason to know that her husband is close by, that he rejects the opportunity to unwittingly cover the fault. And she certainly does not know that David is unscrupulously engineering Uriah's death.
A few days pass. Someone else knocks on the door. More difficult news. Now alone with a growing baby inside her, she grieves and weeps again, wailing loudly now.
And God sees. The second non-David sending of the story is where God sends the prophet Nathan. God takes the story and rewrites it. David can no longer play God and recognises the depth of his mistakes; his heart breaks and he changes his verb. He takes in Bathsheba. She is protected. In time, her swollen belly shudders in waves of pain. She is frightened again, comforted now by the women around her.
The baby is born, but in another painful twist, he is small and weak, unlikely to live.
David fasts and prays for the boy, but Bathsheba, her breasts aching with milk, also yearns for her son. This little one's very existence cost the life of Uriah. If he dies what will happen to her? What will happen to her family? She holds her breath, willing him to breathe.
Please God, rewrite this.
Please.
please?
And the little one dies.
The text is silent, but Bathsheba's heart must have screamed. Was it not enough to lose her husband and to be the plaything and trophy of a powerful man? Now to lose her child, whose tiny fingers reminded her of her own; whose eyes craved light and life.
But this is not the end of Bathsheba's story - God has provided a way out and a new future. David accepts her, loves her, gives her status. He takes mercy on her. Bathsheba rises and bears more sons, including Solomon - whose name is Peace. A son loved and chosen by God to succeed David on the throne.
And in the following years, Bathsheba gains a voice for herself. She finds herself in a court where God is feared and honoured. She hears Psalms sung and stories told of God's mercy and justice, both in David's life and in the generations before. By the time of David's death, Bathsheba is confident, clear and assertive. She listens to men, speaks to them and for them; aware that her own voice now carries weight.
No longer judged by her looks or her backstory, she is now the mother of the king. No more grinding her own flour or long hours tending animals and children. People come to her. I wonder what she told her children and grandchildren about how David came to be part of her story? Could she redeem that? Does she need to? Perhaps only God gets to do that fully. Bathsheba was not forgotten or rejected by God. The silenced woman gains and voice and is no longer ignored.
Today we see Bathsheba as a broken character in a story and we have only a few clues to go on, but for me they are enough to indicate God's power to turn a story around and bring blessing and hope. Although there is pain along the way, the pain is not the whole story. The episode we recall is not the whole story of the person created and loved by God.
I pray that my own legacy will be God-honouring and not hijacked by circumstance. But even it if were, God's mercy, acceptance, love and comfort are still true. No story defines me. Or you. Or Bathsheba.
------
2 Samuel 11 is not the only time Bathsheba appears in the Bible. She's alluded to in Matthew 1 as one of Jesus' ancestors, appears at the end of David's life in 1 Kings 1 and 2, and gets a mention in the title of Psalm 51. Four of her children are named in 1 Chronicles 3: Shammua, Shobab, Nathan and Solomon. There is a hint that her grandfather might have been Ahithophel, a trusted advisor to David (her father Eliab's name may be listed in 2 Samuel 23:34).
------
Lucy Marfleet loves reading, laughing, her husband’s cooking, walking her dog and marvelling at how tall the kids are getting. She teaches Biblical Studies for Spurgeon’s College on their Equipped to Minister course and has a Masters in Theology from the International Baptist Theological Seminary. See her blog at www.lucymarfleet.com
Pictures from Pixabay
That's such a powerful analysis of her and you raise so many points I hadn't considered. Maybe it's been convenient for people throughout history to see Bathsheba as culpable because it takes the focus off David, about whom we'd rather believe the best. We're just not very good at seeing people in their complexity and I think we prefer 'David the psalmist' or 'David, God's chosen king' to the seamier sides of him. Anyway, perhaps you should write a book about her. There's so much here that you could develop further. I'll put my pre-order in here!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Fran. Hadn't thought of a book, but the cogs are whirring now...
DeleteAmanda Bedzrah has written a fascinating story, from Bathsheba's POV, which touches on many of the things you've mentioned Lucy, though some details are different. Yours is a super-balanced approach, very much appreciated. I think that to blame her, or to place on her some kind of longing for David before this happened, is seriously missing the inference of the text. Well done.
DeleteThanks Natasha, I've not read Amanda's book, but there is plenty we can identify with as women and clues to help us put more of the puzzle together from the text. Filling the spaces is a real art, however :)
DeleteBeautiful post, Lucy! It was great stepping right in to Bathsheba's head and shoes!! I think a bad name once gained sticks over the good deeds in man's eyes but than God it's not like that in Papa God's eyes!! I have truly never seen anyone bear the name Bathsheba!! Lovely post.
ReplyDeleteThank you Sophia - and what you say resonates with Samuel's experience of meeting Jesse's family too. God looks at the heart.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThanks. Blessings.
ReplyDeleteYes, very well expressed, Lucy. I think Bathsheba's story is just one of the strands in the family drama that is brilliantly narrated in 2 Samuel 11 - 1 Kings 2. There are other women victims and assertive men who seal their own fate. Joab's role in the ongoing story is quite a feature. I also wonder if the writer is deliberately showing how Hannah's words in 1 Samuel 2 work out in practice.
ReplyDeletePretty sure there is a Hannah link and this would be a great theme to explore in the narrative of Samuel-Kings. How many women and oppressed people find their circumstances redeemed? I had thought of Hannah but decided that was a detail too far for one post. Joab is a right old character too, of course. Not many Joabs around, either...
DeleteGreat post! The Bible lays the blame for this firmly on David's shoulders. As per Nathan the prophet's stinging rebuke. And as David himself acknowledges, in his gut-wrenching Psalm 51. Adultery and murder are heavy sins, and the poor innocent baby suffered the consequences (as did Bathsheba) - the taint of what David had done also affects his family afterwards.
ReplyDeleteI can understand those who think this was rape because of the power imbalance - no woman could refuse the King without severe consequences. And yet it's complicated, since we have no idea what Bathsheba's feelings for David actually were. It bothers me a little that some feminists seem always want to frame women as victims. Not because sexism isn't real, but because I think many women are survivors, precisely because of misogyny and oppression past and present. I therefore don't see Bathsheba as broken, but as a survivor. And the Bible still doesn't blame her.
I studied with a group of international students who placed the blame squarely on Bathsheba, as she allowed herself to be seen washing. These were men, from the Middle East, but it really did get me thinking.
DeleteI agree that we don't have a full picture and don't know if there was any degree of consent, but I would suggest that the burden of responsibility lies utterly with David; rape victims can feel guilt and grooming victims can believe they led their abusers on. What if that emotional attachment is not their responsibility at all?
Definitely a survivor. And blessed by God, even through and despite the painful stories. Thank you!
Thank you for this. There are so many other things here as well, all of which add to the fascination of the story. Trace the references back, and both Bathsheba's husband and father seem to be listed in "The Thirty", one of David's elite military groups - making Bathsheba a "military wife". Trace Ahithophel's reaction to Absalom's rebellion - was he angry with how David had treated his granddaughter? - and his untimely and tragic death. Trace the impact on David's family, and it's possibly 10, maybe 15 years before his spiritual vitality returns, around the time of his ill-judged census and the vision at the threshing floor. Add to that the contrast in character between David (the Israelite) and Uriah (the Hittite, so possibly a foreigner?) which highlights how far David had gone down in his scheming ...
ReplyDeleteMartin - so glad someone else picked up on the Ahithophel and '30' links. There is disagreement over whether the Ahithophel listed is the same one as the chap who advises the king, but I think the connection is tantalising. All the characters connected with David seem to have a complicated story and none come out of it looking good. Totally agree that the details reinforce the gravity of the fall of David.
DeleteBrilliant piece, and very thought provoking. Bathsheba is such a fascinating woman.
ReplyDeleteSuch a great piece Lucy. Absolutely fascinating and so well reasoned. Amanda's book is great, a very good read which dives deep, but like others, I see a story coming out of this in your voice.
ReplyDeleteWhen I was a child I knew a Bathsheba! She was known as "Batchy" as a nickname, possibly because it was a mouthful but also it's connotation. I wonder why her parents named her that? Incidentally, I've always read that story and seen it as being David's fall from grace. Never thought about it being her fault.
ReplyDeleteGreat post. And I cannot add anything to all the above comments which equally develop your thoughts. I just want to pick up one word - toward the end. Mercy. Whoever is to blame, David and/or Bathsheba...and it's impossible to accurately apportion blame in this story or in our own lives...to run into the mercy of God is humbling. 'Pain is not the whole story' - so well put.
ReplyDelete