Journeying with Jane



Image by Martine from Pixabay

I’ve just borrowed some Jane Austen novels from the library. It’s a long time since I read any Austen, but several screen adaptations of her work are my gold standard for book-to-film adaptations: the gorgeous 1995 BBC Pride and Prejudice, Ang Lee’s wonderful 1995 film version of Sense and Sensibility (screenplay by Emma Thompson), and – perhaps the best of all – the sensitive and moving BBC 1995 Persuasion, starring Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds. Amy Heckerling’s 1995 comedy Clueless also deserves recognition: set in a Californian high school, it’s a delightfully witty riff on Emma, with Alicia Silverstone as the ditzy but lovable Cher.

I haven’t cared for any Austen adaptations since.

Reading Northanger Abbey – it must be 30 years since I last read it – I am struck by how realistic a portrayal of a teenage girl Catherine Morland is. Catherine is naïve, easily impressed and somewhat gullible. She’s also sweet-tempered, genuine, honest, and has strong moral principles that help her learn from her mistakes. (And Henry Tilney is possibly my favourite of all Austen’s heroes, along with Emma’s Mr Knightley.)

Reading an Austen novel is to time-travel. It takes you into such a different world. The England of 1813 – the year in which Pride and Prejudice was finally published – is a different planet from the England of 1913, and certainly the England of 2025. Jane Austen’s characters, at the start of the 19th century, were to see massive social change that they could not have imagined in their own lifetimes. I find this moving. Cultures change, massively so. Human nature doesn’t. The characters of Jane Austen’s novels – whether endearing, honourable and admirable, or ordinary and gossipy, or downright vapid, corrupt and amoral – provide a microcosm of human nature as we experience it every day.

That’s one of the reasons why we should read the classics. Jane Austen was also ground-breaking, a quietly powerful writer who challenged literary and social conventions and changed the novel form forever.

It’s important that we writers read a lot. Reading enriches our imaginations, sharpens our minds and helps us learn from the best – or the worst! – about the art of writing. You may not be into Jane Austen, and that’s fine. I wouldn’t classify myself as a Janeite either. But what are YOUR favourite classics? And by classic I mean anything written up to the 1980s. The 80s, after all, were now 40 years ago.

I’ll leave the final word with Jane’s brother Henry, who wrote this moving tribute to her in his Biographical Notice in the 1817 edition of Northanger Abbey:

‘Jane Austen was buried on the 24th of July, 1817, in the cathedral church of Winchester, which, in the whole catalogue of its mighty dead, does not contain the ashes of a brighter genius or sincerer Christian.’



I’m a Licensed Lay Minister in the Diocese of Rochester. I also work full-time for the United Reformed Church at URC Church House. I wrote a devotional for the anthology Light for the Writer’s Soul, published by Media Associates International, and my short story ‘Magnificat’ appears in the ACW anthology Merry Christmas Everyone.

Comments

  1. Well this is right up my street! (It's Ruth, by the way). I agree - I love Northanger Abbey. Classics? I Little Women, The Secret Garden, A Little Princess, anything by Trollope or Mrs Gaskell, Barbara Pym - I could go on. I am right in the middle of my last round of edits on the second Pride & Prejudice book so this is most timely. It's all tamboured muslin and chaises here!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ruth! Heh, I now know what tamboured muslin is! I loved A Little Princess and The Secret Garden. Also a big Anne of Green Gables fan. I confess I've never read Trollope, sounds like I should. I enjoyed Dickens a lot back in the day.

      Delete
  2. Lovely post, Philippa! Thanks. I read Persuasion in 1976 and haven't read any other Jane Austen book. We read it for our GCSE exams then. Good advice that we continue reading to help our imagination. I enjoyed Dickens' books, and I did enjoy Lady Chatterley's Lover. I will soon read 'Gone With the Wind. Classics can be fun. Blessings.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Philippa, your post got me thinking that maybe I should reread a classic, I have a shelf full of them. My favourites would be Charlotte Bronte - especially Jane Eyre, also enjoyed Arnold Bennett (including Anna of the 5 towns) and Nevil Shute - Pied Piper and others. Always hard to choose favourites.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dostoyevsky's Crime & Punishment would have to be up there. Unashamedly Christian and magnificent, even though I was thrown by the patronymic naming. Steinbeck - just about anything he wrote, though Grapes of Wrath is unbeatable. I agree with Meryl, Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre is almost perfect. And I do wonder whether Jostein Gaarder's novels will be considered to be classics in the years to come.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Gillian Poucher9 June 2025 at 11:12

    There are so many classics I still aspire to read, especially by Dickens, 'Great Expectations' being my favourite of the ones I've read. Of Jane Austen, 'Persuasion' is a close second for me along with 'P&P.' I love George Eliot's 'Middlemarch', Hardy's 'Tess' and Bronte's 'Jane Eyre.' 'Little Women', the 'Anne' books and Nevil Shute take me back to childhood and teen reads. It feels quite nostalgic thinking about them all - thank you!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment